DRAGENwiki · Article
Conditioned Motivating Operations
Customize your experience
Sources checked. Clinical review pending.
A conditioned motivating operation is a sign, a place or an event that changes how much something is worth to a person only because of what they have learned, like a clock that makes lunch matter more or a missing piece that makes the piece worth asking for.
Conditioned motivating operations in 60 seconds
- The value change is learned. A conditioned motivating operation (CMO) works because of a person's learning history, not because of an unlearned need. [1][3]
- Three kinds have been proposed. Surrogate (CMO-S), reflexive (CMO-R) and transitive (CMO-T). [1]
- Some signs make escape worth more. A cue that has come before hard work can make getting away from it worth more, though not for every learner. [1][4]
- A missing piece can teach asking. Children have learned to ask for an item missing from an activity they already liked. [1][7]
- The names are debated. Some authors argue that the CMO-R and CMO-T labels add nothing, while the procedures behind them still matter. [2][4]
Jump to: What a CMO is · Surrogate · Reflexive · Transitive · Missing piece · The debate · Fix the work · Example · Mistakes · Words to know · Need a PDF? · More from DRAGEN · Sources
This page is free, like the rest of DRAGENwiki. It builds on the main page about motivating operations, and its partner is unconditioned motivating operations.
What a conditioned motivating operation is
Plain words first. Some things matter more to you only because of what has happened before: the clock reading noon, a coworker's sigh before bad news, or a missing key when you are locked out. None of these would matter to someone with no history at all.
The term. Behavior analysts call events like these conditioned motivating operations. The tutorial by Langthorne and McGill puts it this way: "Other events acquire their value-altering effects as a result of the person's learning history." [1] The UMO page explains the other kind, the ones that need no learning.
Two effects, like every MO. A CMO changes how much a consequence is worth, and it changes how often a person does what has gotten that consequence before. [1] To evoke a behavior means to make it more likely right now.
An older name. Michael's earlier papers used the term establishing operation. He wrote that "Operations such as deprivation have two different effects on behavior." [5] Later, he separated unlearned ones from those "that depend on the learning history of the organism." [3]
Three kinds. "Three forms of CMOs have been proposed: surrogate CMOs, reflexive CMOs, and transitive CMOs." [1] Each gets its own section below.
The surrogate CMO (CMO-S)
What it is. A surrogate CMO is a sign that used to mean nothing. After it has been paired with another motivating operation, it may take on some of that operation's effect. [1][3]
The tutorial's example. Someone who always eats lunch at noon. After many days of hunger at 12:00, the time on the clock may come to make food matter more on its own. [1] The clock stands in for the hunger, which is why it is called a surrogate.
Attention to someone else. The tutorial suggests that a caregiver talking with another person may work this way for some children, since those moments have come with less attention. [1] O'Reilly and colleagues worked with two participants with severe developmental disabilities, and with their parents. [6] "A modified attention condition was introduced, which involved both parents interacting with a third person." [6]
What helped. "Treatment consisted of the parents delivering attention on a fixed-time schedule during this specific social context." [6] Fixed-time means on a clock, whatever the person is doing. "Results indicated that the treatment reduced problem behavior." [6] "Follow-up evaluations with 1 participant indicated maintenance of treatment effects for up to 6 months." [6]
In plain words. The parents gave attention on a set clock schedule, during the very moments that had been hard. [6] The tutorial explains why this can work: once those moments no longer come with less attention, they can lose their pull. [1]
A caution. Poling, Lotfizadeh and Edwards write that, to their knowledge, "there is no published demonstration of the use of a CMO-S to improve behavior in an applied setting." [2] So treat the surrogate CMO label as one possible explanation, not a proven one. [2]
The reflexive CMO (CMO-R)
What it is. A reflexive CMO is a sign whose start has gone along with things getting worse, or better. [1] So it changes the value of its own removal, or of its own staying. [1] It acts on itself, which is why it is called reflexive. [3]
The common case. A cue that has come before hard or unpleasant work can make getting away from that cue worth more. [1] Then, behavior that has ended that cue before becomes more likely. [1]
The gloves. The tutorial describes a study by Carr, Newsom and Binkoff with two boys. For one of them, the experimenter's gloves coming off had gone along with the end of demands. [1] For the other, it was a buttoning board being taken away. [1] When the gloves came off, aggression fell to low levels. When the gloves stayed on, aggression stayed high, even though no demands were given at all. [1] The tutorial's reading: "The glove therefore makes escape more valuable (not more available) and as such functions as a CMO-R." [1]
Taking the glove off is not enough. "As Michael (2007) noted, however, such an intervention would be ineffective without attending to those aspects of the demand that led to the glove acquiring aversive properties in the first instance." [1] In plain words: if the work stays hard, taking away the sign does not fix the reason it mattered. [1]
What the tutorial lists instead. It names several ways to make the work itself less aversive: reinforcement for doing the task, tasks inside preferred activities, errorless learning, fading in instructions slowly, and choice of tasks. [1]
The cue is not the cause. A folder or a voice matters because of what it has come with. [1] If the work stays the same, a new neutral cue that comes with it can take on the same effect. [1]
The transitive CMO (CMO-T)
What it is. A transitive CMO is an event that makes something else worth more. [1] It often shows up while a person is doing a chain of steps and one step is blocked. [1][2] Michael's abstract says a transitive CEO "establishes some other stimulus as a form of effective reinforcement" [3].
The drink machine. The tutorial's example: a person is buying a soft drink, but has the wrong change. [1] The sight of the machine, which would normally be a cue to buy, now makes the right change worth more, and makes asking the shop assistant for change more likely. [1]
It depends on wanting the end. The CMO-T works only if the person wants the drink right now. [1] If they are not thirsty, the wrong change is not expected to make them ask. [1]
The locked fridge. The tutorial's other example is a person who lives in a residential home where the refrigerator is locked. The lock can make a staff member with the key worth more, and can make behavior that has worked before more likely, such as aggression. [1] "In the absence of the lock on the refrigerator, the reinforcing value of the staff member with a key is abolished." [1] In plain words: with no lock, the person with the key is not special, and asking or aggression about it fades. [1] It also depends on the person wanting food at that moment. [1]
A DRAGEN note on locks. A lock on food or drink is a rights question before it is a behavior question. When behavior happens near a locked fridge or door, first ask why it is locked.
Asking for a missing piece
The teaching idea. Asking for what you want is called a mand. Albert and colleagues define it simply: "More simply, a mand is a request for a preferred event." [7] A CMO-T can create a natural reason to ask. [1][7]
What the study did. Three children with autism, ages 5 to 8, took part. [7] For each child, the team chose three activities the child already liked. [7] "Participants were first taught to complete 3 behavior chains." [7] A behavior chain is a set of steps done in order, like making a sandwich. [7] "Subsequently, the chains were interrupted by removing 1 item needed to complete each chain to contrive motivating operations (MOs) as a means of teaching mands for missing items." [7]
How the asking was taught. At the step where the item was needed, the instructor waited ten seconds. [7] If the child had not asked, the instructor said the item's name as a model. When the child said it back, the item came right away and the activity went on. [7] Over time, the spoken model was faded out. [7]
The study's baseline, and DRAGEN's rule. Before teaching began, if a child did not ask within the ten seconds, the instructor ended that activity and put its items away. [7] DRAGEN does this differently: if the learner does not ask, hand the piece over and keep the activity going.
What happened. The study reports that "all participants emitted unprompted mands for the missing items within the context of the trained chains and within the context of novel, untrained chains." [7] Unprompted means the child asked with no model. "All participants also demonstrated tact responses relative to the missing items as a result of the mand training." [7] A tact is naming something you notice.
It lasted. "Once learned, these unprompted mand responses were well maintained under the control of the transitive conditioned establishing operation (CEO-T) without requiring supplemental prompts, such as the presence of the item or a vocal prompt from the instructor." [7]
Why this matters for families. The activities were ones each child already liked, and only one item needed to finish was missing. [7] That is the kind of reason to ask that DRAGEN uses: a piece of something the learner enjoys, never a held-back need.
Why the names are debated
Two critiques. Poling and colleagues, and Edwards and Poling, argue that some CMO labels add words without adding understanding. [2][4]
On the CMO-R. "In our opinion, CMO-R is a term and a concept devoid of value." [2] Edwards and Poling add: "The CMO-R terminology, however, is superfluous, adding complexity without enhancing precision and promoting the incorrect assumption that the functions of relevant stimulus presentations are fixed." [4] And: "The CMO-R is inferred, not empirically demonstrated." [4]
Not every child reacts the same way. Edwards and Poling point to a study of demands: "A major problem with the analysis proposed by Carbone et al. (2010) is that not all children exposed to the same demand conditions responded to escape." [4] In plain words, the same demand was not a problem for everyone.
On the CMO-T. "Simply put, the CMO-T concept is unnecessary." [2] They suggest describing the missing-piece procedure as a chain extension procedure, with one more link added to the chain. [2]
On the word conditioned. "It is the behavior of the individual that is conditioned, not the operation." [2]
What both papers keep. The procedures still matter. "Practitioners should be aware of the procedures used in these studies and use them to benefit clients when appropriate, regardless of what they are called." [2] And: "Intervening variables can be useful heuristics, but they are not explanatory concepts." [4] A heuristic is a shortcut for thinking, not a cause.
A practical reading for DRAGEN work. You do not need to win this debate to help a child. Use the labels to think, not to explain. Describe what happens before, during and after, and change the parts you can.
Fix the work, not the learner
DRAGEN's rules for CMOs. These are page rules from the four pillars, not findings:
- A missing piece belongs to a fun activity. Only set up a missing piece for an activity the learner chose and enjoys.
- Never hold back a need. Never hold back food, drink, rest, the bathroom, comfort or a communication device to make asking happen.
- If the learner does not ask, hand it over. Model the word, give the piece, and keep the activity going. No pressure, no lost turn.
- When a cue predicts hard work, change the work. Make tasks easier, shorter, more chosen and more rewarding, as the tutorial suggests. [1] Do not just hide the cue.
- Teach a clear way to ask for a break. Then honor it, every time at first.
- Tell the family first. Explain any setup on purpose, and get consent before it starts.
- A BCBA reviews the plan. Any plan that arranges a CMO on purpose is reviewed by a BCBA.
A no is information. Saying no, asking a question, or taking back a yes tells you about the task, the timing or the person's needs. It is not noncompliance, and it is not a treatment target.
Safety is a separate question. If someone could get hurt right now, handle safety first. Do not use safety as a reason to stop listening to dissent.
This page is general information, not medical or legal advice. A BCBA reviews every clinical decision.
A made-up example: Learner A
Learner A is six and loves painting. A also pushes papers away and cries when a blue homework folder comes out.
The question. The team's assessment, led by the BCBA, suggests the blue folder has come before long, hard worksheets. Getting the folder put away now seems to be worth a lot to A.
The plan, made with the family:
- Painting time with the brush left out of reach. A has learned to point. When A points or says "brush," A gets it right away.
- If A does not ask within a few seconds, the parent says "brush" and hands it over. Painting goes on either way.
- Homework with the blue folder is changed: two short pages, A picks which comes first, a favorite song between them.
- A "break please" card that is honored every time at first.
Listening to A. When A pushes the folder away, the parent pauses and asks what is hard. That is information, not defiance.
Measuring. The family counts how often A asks for the brush and for breaks, and notes each protest at homework time, for two weeks. The BCBA reviews the counts with them and adjusts the plan. No result is promised; the data decide the next step.
Common mistakes
- "A CMO is just a cue." A cue signals that something is available. A CMO changes how much it is worth. [1][3][5]
- "Calling it a CMO-R explains the behavior." Some authors argue the label is inferred, not shown, and explains nothing by itself. [2][4]
- "A CMO-T means holding back what a learner needs." In the study above, the missing item was one piece of an activity the child already liked. [7] DRAGEN never holds back food, drink, rest, comfort or a communication device.
- "Every child finds demands aversive." Not every child exposed to the same demands responded to escape. [4]
- "Just hide the cue." If the work stays hard, removing the cue is not enough. [1]
- "The terms are settled." Published authors still disagree about whether the CMO-R and CMO-T labels are useful. [2][4]
Words to know
- Conditioned motivating operation (CMO): an event that changes how much something is worth because of a person's learning history. [1]
- Surrogate CMO (CMO-S): a sign that has been paired with another motivating operation and now works a bit like it. [1]
- Reflexive CMO (CMO-R): a sign that makes its own ending worth more, or less, because of what it has come before. [1]
- Transitive CMO (CMO-T): an event that makes something else worth more, often when a chain of steps is blocked. [1][3]
- Mand: a request for something a person wants right now. [7]
- Tact: naming something you notice. The children in the study above also learned to name the missing items. [7]
- Behavior chain: a set of steps done in order, like making a sandwich. [7]
- Fixed-time schedule: giving something on a clock, whatever the person is doing. The O'Reilly study gave attention this way. [6]
- Learning history: everything a person has experienced that shapes what matters to them now. [1]
Need a PDF?
Create it here, for free: the DRAGEN app. Use it at your next session or family meeting.
Or print one we already made, also free:
- Ask cards (PDF)
- Behavior interview: what, when, and what happens after (PDF)
- 4-term data sheet (PDF)
- Scatterplot: when does it happen? (PDF)
- Four functions quick-check (PDF)
- Every free PDF
More from DRAGEN
- Lesson: How to teach a child to ask instead (FCT)
- Lesson: How to take 4-term contingency data
- Lesson: How to tell the four functions of behavior apart
- Lesson: How to use reinforcement at home, without bribing
- Free app for parents: DRAGENparent
- BCBA care: DRAGENtherapy
- Books: DRAGENbooks
- Talk with Chase: Contact
- Home: dragen.cloud
Related DRAGENwiki pages: motivating operations · unconditioned motivating operations · establishing operation · abolishing operation · discriminative stimulus · mand · functional communication training · escape function · respondent conditioning · the right to say no
What remains unknown
- The CMO-S in practice. One paper reports that, to its authors' knowledge, no published study has used a CMO-S to improve behavior in an applied setting. [2]
- The CMO-R. Whether it is a real, separate process is argued; one paper calls it inferred, not shown. [4]
- The CMO-T label. Whether it adds anything beyond describing a behavior chain is argued. [2]
- Small studies. The studies described here had two or three participants each. [6][7] They show what can happen, not what will happen for your child.
- This page was last checked on 2026-11-12.
Sources
- Langthorne, P., & McGill, P. (2009). A tutorial on the concept of the motivating operation and its importance to application. Behavior Analysis in Practice, 2(2), 22–31. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC2859803/
- Poling, A., Lotfizadeh, A. D., & Edwards, T. L. (2020). Motivating operations and discriminative stimuli: Distinguishable but interactive variables. Behavior Analysis in Practice, 13(2), 502–508. https://doi.org/10.1007/s40617-019-00400-2 (read at https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC7314879/)
- Michael, J. (1993). Establishing operations. The Behavior Analyst, 16(2), 191–206. https://doi.org/10.1007/BF03392623 (abstract read at https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC2733648/)
- Edwards, T. L., & Poling, A. (2020). Motivating operations and negative reinforcement. Perspectives on Behavior Science, 43(4), 761–778. https://doi.org/10.1007/s40614-020-00266-8 (read at https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC7724015/)
- Michael, J. (1982). Distinguishing between discriminative and motivational functions of stimuli. Journal of the Experimental Analysis of Behavior, 37(1), 149–155. https://doi.org/10.1901/jeab.1982.37-149 (abstract read at https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC1333126/)
- O'Reilly, M. F., Lancioni, G. E., King, L., Lally, G., & Dhomhnaill, O. N. (2000). Using brief assessments to evaluate aberrant behavior maintained by attention. Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis, 33(1), 109–112. https://doi.org/10.1901/jaba.2000.33-109 (abstract read at https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC1284231/)
- Albert, K. M., Carbone, V. J., Murray, D. D., Hagerty, M., & Sweeney-Kerwin, E. J. (2012). Increasing the mand repertoire of children with autism through the use of an interrupted chain procedure. Behavior Analysis in Practice, 5(2), 65–76. https://doi.org/10.1007/BF03391825 (read at https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC3592491/)