DRAGENwiki · Article
Abolishing Operation
Customize your experience
Sources checked. Clinical review pending.
An abolishing operation is an event that makes something worth less to a person for now, and makes the behavior that has gotten it before less likely.
Abolishing operations in 60 seconds
- It lowers value. An abolishing operation (AO) makes a reinforcer, or a punisher, less effective for a while. [1]
- It abates behavior. At the same time, behavior that has produced that consequence becomes less likely. [1]
- Having had plenty is the everyday version. After free access to an item, people tend to choose it less. [2][3]
- Lower behavior does not always mean an AO. When a planned schedule of free access lowers a behavior, the reason can be satiation, extinction or other good things to do. [5][6]
- The moment before matters. What happens just before a session or an assessment can change what you see in it. [4][7][9]
Jump to: What an AO is · AOs change choices · Not extinction · AOs in everyday plans · When attention backfires · Plenty, not loss · Example · Mistakes · Words to know · Need a PDF? · More from DRAGEN · Sources
This page is free, like the rest of DRAGENwiki. It builds on the main page about motivating operations and is the partner of establishing operation.
What an abolishing operation is
Plain words first. Sometimes a person has had enough of something. After a big glass of water, more water matters less. After an hour of a favorite show, the show matters less. Whatever lowered the value is the abolishing operation.
The classic example. Langthorne and McGill use an athlete. A drink is worth a lot after a long run, "whereas it is abolished after he has consumed a large quantity of water". [1] They add: "Likewise, the probability of the athlete displaying the same behavior abates after drinking a large quantity of water." [1]
Two effects at once. An AO does two things together:
- Value goes down. In the tutorial's words, "an abolishing operation (AO) abolishes the effectiveness of a particular form of reinforcement or punishment". [1]
- Behavior goes down. It abates, meaning lowers, behavior that has produced that consequence in the past. [1]
Two verbs to know. Behavior analysts say an establishing operation evokes behavior and an abolishing operation abates it. Abate simply means makes less likely, for now. [1]
Having had plenty is the common case. Behavior analysts call this satiation. Writing about food, water and similar things, the tutorial says: "Satiation of these types of stimuli abolishes their reinforcing value and abates associated behaviors." [1]
It is temporary. An AO works for now. After the person goes without again, the value returns. That return is an establishing operation. [1]
Punishers work the other way. An AO can also make a punisher less effective. For behavior that a punisher has held down, the direction flips, the reverse of the reinforcer case. [1]
AOs change what people choose
What a preference assessment is. A preference assessment asks a person to choose among items, to learn what they like most right now. See preference assessment.
Plenty lowers choice. Gottschalk, Libby and Graff worked with four individuals with developmental disabilities. Before some assessments, one item had been unavailable for 48 hours. Before others, the person had 10 minutes of free access to it. [2] "Deprivation resulted in increased preference, whereas satiation resulted in decreased preference compared to control conditions." [2]
A second study. McAdam and colleagues worked with three people with developmental disabilities and three typically developing preschool children, using a paired-choice format. [3] "For each participant, at least two items were chosen less frequently following the satiation condition compared to the control condition." [3]
Even favorites. Each person also stopped choosing at least one item after satiation, though every item had been highly or moderately preferred at the start. [3]
Choice is not the same as reinforcement. McAdam and colleagues name a limit: "a reinforcer assessment was not included in the current study, so the ability of the items used to maintain or increase behavior was unknown." [3] A drop in choice suggests a drop in value. It does not prove it.
Variety may help. McAdam and colleagues describe DeLeon and colleagues (2000): a rotating set of toys reduced one girl's self-injury more than a single set, "suggesting that satiation limited the effectiveness of the single set of toys." [3]
The moment before counts. Berg and colleagues ran a two-choice assessment after 10 minutes of free play or 10 minutes of playing alone. They concluded: "The results of this study show that events occurring immediately prior to an assessment condition can influence behavior within the assessment." [4]
A practical rule for DRAGEN work. Before a preference assessment, note what the person just had. Repeat the assessment on different days. If a favorite suddenly drops, ask first whether the person just had plenty of it.
An AO is not extinction
A common treatment. In noncontingent reinforcement (NCR), a person gets something they value on a schedule, whatever they are doing. See noncontingent reinforcement.
Two explanations. Hagopian and colleagues write: "Reductions in problem behavior using NCR have frequently been attributed to both satiation of the reinforcer and extinction." [6]
- Satiation is an AO. The person has plenty, so the behavior that used to get it matters less. [1]
- Extinction is different. The behavior no longer produces the reinforcer. See extinction.
A third explanation. Hagopian and colleagues studied four participants. "It is proposed that reductions in problem behavior observed during NCR interventions may be a function of the availability of alternative sources of reinforcement." [6] In plain words, having other good things to do may matter too.
It differs by person. Kahng and colleagues tested a method for telling satiation from extinction with three participants. "Results suggested that the operative mechanisms of NCR were idiosyncratic across the 3 participants and appeared to change during treatment for 1 of the participants." [5]
Giving can do two things. The tutorial notes: "Likewise, providing access to food may reinforce food-maintained behaviors but may also serve to abolish the effectiveness of food as a reinforcer." [1]
Why it matters. Satiation depends on how much of something a person has had. Extinction depends on whether the behavior still pays off. They call for different changes, so a BCBA looks at the data before deciding which one is at work.
AOs in everyday plans
Attention before a session. McComas, Thompson and Johnson worked with elementary-school children with a range of disabilities. They compared 10 minutes of attention with 10 minutes of being ignored before sessions. [7] "Results indicated that participants who displayed attention-maintained problem behavior displayed less problem behavior following presession exposure to attention than when ignored." [7]
Only when the function matches. "No such effect was found for presession attention on escape-maintained problem behavior." [7] The authors discuss "matching antecedent-based interventions to the results of functional analysis". [7] See functional analysis.
In classrooms. Rispoli and colleagues worked with two students with autism. Before class, the students had, or did not have, the items linked to their problem behavior. [8] "Results suggested that presession access may result in lower levels of problem behavior and higher levels of academic engagement during classroom instruction." [8]
Rest is a need. The tutorial describes a study by Horner, Day and Day (1997) with a boy who was tired: "Allowing the boy to have a nap appeared to function as an AO and reduced the occurrence of problem behavior." [1]
A better day. The tutorial describes replacing EOs for problem behavior with AOs, such as plenty of social contact, access to favorite items, fewer unpleasant events and enough to do. [1] It describes this kind of change as giving the person a better quality of life, citing McGill (1999). [1]
Not the whole plan. The tutorial cites Iwata and colleagues (1993): "interventions that solely involve the modification of MOs do not disrupt the contingencies that maintain problem behavior". [1] When the AO wears off, the behavior can come back. [1] So pair it with teaching an easier way to ask, as in functional communication training.
When attention raises value instead
A surprise. Roantree and Kennedy worked with a 10-year-old boy with severe disabilities. Before some functional analysis sessions, he had 20 minutes of attention, with positive comments every 30 seconds. [9]
What happened. Without the attention beforehand, his stereotypy looked about the same in every condition. With it, stereotypy was high in the attention condition. When the attention beforehand was withdrawn, that effect reversed. [9] Their title says it plainly: the attention given first worked as an establishing operation, not an abolishing one. [9]
What other studies show. The authors note that earlier analyses show "presession attention can serve as an AO for attention as a positive reinforcer." [9] Their case went the other way.
Why it might flip. They offer a possibility: "It is possible that a curvilinear relation exists between exposure to presession attention and its effect as either an EO or AO, with EO effects occurring initially and AO effects emerging over time." [9] In plain words, attention may first raise its own value, and only later lower it. They add: "However, such a functional relation remains to be empirically demonstrated." [9]
One event, two effects. The tutorial describes Berg and colleagues: a young girl played with her mother more after time alone, and with toys more after lots of her mother's attention. [1] "As such, a single event (e.g., access to maternal attention) may function as both an EO and an AO for responses maintained by different consequences." [1]
What to take from this. Roantree and Kennedy write that people who do functional assessments "need to consider the possibility that presession events can serve as either AOs or EOs for attention." [9] Do not assume that more of something will lower its value. Check with data.
Plenty, without taking things away
The usual way to shift a preference. Hanley and colleagues wanted preschool children to spend more time in less popular areas. They wrote: "One strategy to promote selection of important but less preferred activities is to limit access to children's most preferred activities." [10]
The way they tested. They describe "A more acceptable alternative, which retains the preferred activities during free play" [10]: long, free access to the popular activities, so that children would want them less afterward. [10]
What they found. The study included 20 children aged three and a half to five and a half. [10] "Thirteen of the 20 children were observed in a target zone more often during the satiation phase relative to the initial baseline phase." [10]
Embedding helped more. The team also added highly reinforcing materials and interactions to the less popular areas. Time in those areas rose just under twofold with satiation, and just under sixfold with embedded reinforcement. [10]
No guarantee. Satiation raised time in the instructional and science areas, but not the library. [10] The authors write that "the satiation (or habituation) procedure does not guarantee that a child will reallocate his or her time to a particular activity." [10]
DRAGEN's rules for AOs. These are page rules from the four pillars, not findings:
- In DRAGEN work, an AO means giving plenty and meeting needs: rest, food, attention, comfort and enough to do.
- Never take away food, water, sleep, comfort, safety or affection to change what someone wants.
- Keep choices open. Satiation can be tried while every activity stays available. [10]
- Fewer requests should come from needs being met, not from a person giving up. Asking is how a person tells you what they need.
A no is information. Saying no, asking a question, or taking back a yes tells you about the task, the timing or the person's needs. It is not noncompliance, and it is not a treatment target.
Safety is a separate question. If someone could get hurt right now, handle safety first. Do not use safety as a reason to stop listening to dissent.
This page is general information, not medical or legal advice. A BCBA reviews every clinical decision.
A made-up example: Learner A
Learner A is nine and loves building blocks. In class, A leaves math to get the blocks and shouts when they are put away. Other activities get little of A's time.
The question. The team's assessment, led by the BCBA, suggests the shouting gets A the blocks back. Blocks seem worth the most when A has had none all morning.
The plan, made with the family and the teacher:
- Ten minutes of free block time at the start of each day, to lower the pull of the blocks during math.
- An ask card that says "blocks, please," honored often at first, with a clear time when blocks come back.
- Math in short parts, with blocks used inside the math where they fit.
Listening to A. When A says no to math, the team treats it as information. Is the work too hard, too long, or at the wrong time?
Checking two warnings. Morning block time could make A want blocks more, not less, so the team watches the data. And plenty of blocks does not promise that A will choose math. [9][10]
Measuring. The teacher keeps a simple data sheet for two weeks. The BCBA reviews it with the family and teacher and adjusts the plan. No result is promised; the data decide the next step.
Common mistakes
- "An AO means taking something away." It is usually the opposite: an AO often comes from having had plenty. [1][2]
- "If behavior drops with free access, it must be satiation." It can also be extinction or other good things to do, and it can differ by person. [5][6]
- "Attention first always calms attention-seeking behavior." In one study, attention given first raised its value instead. [9]
- "Attention before the session helps any behavior." One study found it helped attention-maintained behavior, not escape-maintained behavior. [7]
- "If an item is picked less, it no longer works as a reward." Choice dropped after satiation, but reinforcement was not tested. [3]
- "An AO fixes behavior for good." The effect is temporary, and behavior can return when the AO wears off. [1]
- "Satiation will move a child to the activity you want." It does not guarantee which activity a child picks next. [10]
Words to know
- Abolishing operation (AO): an event that makes a consequence less valuable for now and abates related behavior. [1]
- Establishing operation (EO): an event that makes a consequence more valuable for now and evokes related behavior. [1]
- Abate: to make a behavior less likely, for now. [1]
- Satiation: having had plenty of something, which lowers its value for now. [1][2]
- Deprivation: going without something, which raises its value for now. [2]
- Presession: the time just before a teaching or assessment session. [7][9]
- Noncontingent reinforcement (NCR): giving something valued on a schedule, whatever the person is doing. [5][6]
- Preference assessment: a structured way to learn what a person chooses most right now. [2][3]
- Embedded reinforcement: adding highly reinforcing materials or interactions to an activity a person usually skips. [10]
Need a PDF?
Create it here, for free: the DRAGEN app. Use it at your next session or family meeting.
Or print one we already made, also free:
- Free-play preference check, five minutes (PDF)
- Paired-choice preference assessment, six items (PDF)
- MSWO data sheet (PDF)
- What do they love? A reinforcer interview for families (PDF)
- Four functions quick-check (PDF)
- Every free PDF
More from DRAGEN
- Lesson: How to run an MSWO preference assessment
- Lesson: How to use reinforcement at home, without bribing
- Lesson: How to tell the four functions of behavior apart
- Free app for parents: DRAGENparent
- BCBA care: DRAGENtherapy
- Books: DRAGENbooks
- Talk with Chase: Contact
- Home: dragen.cloud
Related DRAGENwiki pages: motivating operations · establishing operation · unconditioned motivating operations · conditioned motivating operations · preference assessment · noncontingent reinforcement · antecedent interventions · functional analysis · attention function · extinction · functional communication training · the right to say no
What remains unknown
- Small studies. One study had one participant, five had two to six, and one had 20 children in a single preschool. [2][3][5][6][8][9][10] They show what can happen, not what will happen for your child.
- Choice is not reinforcement. The preference studies measured what people chose, not whether the items still worked as rewards. [3]
- When attention satisfies and when it fuels. Whether attention first raises and later lowers its own value "remains to be empirically demonstrated." [9]
- Why free access works. The reason NCR lowered behavior varied by person, and changed during treatment for one person. [5]
- This page was last checked on 2026-11-12.
Sources
- Langthorne, P., & McGill, P. (2009). A tutorial on the concept of the motivating operation and its importance to application. Behavior Analysis in Practice, 2(2), 22–31. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC2859803/
- Gottschalk, J. M., Libby, M. E., & Graff, R. B. (2000). The effects of establishing operations on preference assessment outcomes. Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis, 33(1), 85–88. https://doi.org/10.1901/jaba.2000.33-85 (abstract read at https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC1284225/)
- McAdam, D. B., Klatt, K. P., Koffarnus, M., Dicesare, A., Solberg, K., Welch, C., & Murphy, S. (2005). The effects of establishing operations on preferences for tangible items. Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis, 38(1), 107–110. https://doi.org/10.1901/jaba.2005.112-03 (read at https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC1224400/)
- Berg, W. K., Peck, S., Wacker, D. P., Harding, J., McComas, J., Richman, D., & Brown, K. (2000). The effects of presession exposure to attention on the results of assessments of attention as a reinforcer. Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis, 33(4), 463–477. https://doi.org/10.1901/jaba.2000.33-463 (abstract read at https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC1284271/)
- Kahng, S. W., Iwata, B. A., Thompson, R. H., & Hanley, G. P. (2000). A method for identifying satiation versus extinction effects under noncontingent reinforcement schedules. Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis, 33(4), 419–432. https://doi.org/10.1901/jaba.2000.33-419 (abstract read at https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC1284268/)
- Hagopian, L. P., Crockett, J. L., van Stone, M., DeLeon, I. G., & Bowman, L. G. (2000). Effects of noncontingent reinforcement on problem behavior and stimulus engagement: The role of satiation, extinction, and alternative reinforcement. Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis, 33(4), 433–449. https://doi.org/10.1901/jaba.2000.33-433 (abstract read at https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC1284269/)
- McComas, J. J., Thompson, A., & Johnson, L. (2003). The effects of presession attention on problem behavior maintained by different reinforcers. Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis, 36(3), 297–307. https://doi.org/10.1901/jaba.2003.36-297 (abstract read at https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC1284444/)
- Rispoli, M., O'Reilly, M., Lang, R., Machalicek, W., Davis, T., Lancioni, G., & Sigafoos, J. (2011). Effects of motivating operations on problem and academic behavior in classrooms. Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis, 44(1), 187–192. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC3050471/
- Roantree, C. F., & Kennedy, C. H. (2006). A paradoxical effect of presession attention on stereotypy: Antecedent attention as an establishing, not an abolishing, operation. Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis, 39(3), 381–384. https://doi.org/10.1901/jaba.2006.97-05 (read at https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC1702398/)
- Hanley, G. P., Tiger, J. H., Ingvarsson, E. T., & Cammilleri, A. P. (2009). Influencing preschoolers' free-play activity preferences: An evaluation of satiation and embedded reinforcement. Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis, 42(1), 33–41. https://doi.org/10.1901/jaba.2009.42-33 (read at https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC2649843/)